Robert Neulander Wiki Age
Robert Neulander Biography
Robert Neulander was convicted in 2015 of murdering his wife Leslie Neulander, but the verdict was overturned on appeal when the court learned that a jury had exchanged thousands of text messages about the case. Neulander was sentenced to 20 years to life in prison in 2015, but the verdict was appealed and overturned in 2018 for jury misconduct. In October 2019, the New York State Court of Appeals upheld the decision and a new trial was ordered, court records show.
The New York State Court of Appeals decision stated that a juror at the initial trial, Jury 12, was found to have sent and received hundreds of messages during the trial about the Neulander case despite clear instructions. not to discuss the case. He also looked at various media websites that were writing about the trial.
The juror was identified as Johnna Lorraine, who not only received and sent messages about the case, but also attempted to cover up her actions by lying under oath and deleting messages, according to the court’s decision. According to The New York Times, Lorraine was a 23-year-old high school cheerleading coach at the time of the 2015 trial.
Lorraine Sent & Received 7,000 Messages About the Trial & Attempted to Hide Her Actions Afterward
The court was alerted to Lorraine’s actions after the verdict was rendered in Neulander’s first trial, according to a summary from the New York court of appeals. According to the summary, a discharged alternate juror came forward and told defense attorney that the 12th juror Lorraine had “exchanged text messages about the case with third parties while the trial was ongoing and received alerts from the media about the trial on his cell phone. “For example, her father texted her during the trial saying,” Make sure she’s guilty! “And another text message from her friend referred to Neulander as a” scary person. ”
According to the event summary, Lorraine did not share those messages, but instead deleted many of the texts and her web browsing history before handing over her phone for forensic analysts to examine. She also lied in an affidavit when she said that she “followed the instructions of the trial court” at all times during the trial, “according to the report.
The statement of fact provided in the court records showed that Lorraine “secretly and selectively deleted numerous text messages that she believed to be ‘problematic,’ and presented the remaining portions of the text message exchanges to people.” It also showed that it cleared your internet browsing history and was unable to provide an explanation why. Defense attorneys also provided a detailed summary of the jury’s misconduct in writing to the appeals court.
The prosecution argued against overturning the guilty verdict and said that Lorraine’s messages did not show any bias during the trial.
The prosecution argued that although Lorraine engaged in jury misconduct, she was “significantly outmatched by the substantial evidence of guilt presented at trial” and argued against reversing the guilty verdict, according to the appeals court’s decision.
Onondaga County District Attorney William Fitzpatrick said Lorraine’s actions were wrong, but the text messages showed that she was taking her duty as a juror seriously, the Times reported. In one message, he said, “I can’t talk about it,” and in another, “I’ll tell you all about it soon.” Another message asked if Neulander was guilty and she replied, “I can’t say.”
Fitzpatrick pointed to a text sent the night before the verdict that read: “As if someone’s life is actually in our hands! We could send an innocent man to jail or expel a murderer! “The district attorney said that message showed that Lorraine” showed her respect for the jury process and respect for the defendant’s case. ”
The district attorney’s office said Lorraine would not face criminal charges for her actions, the Times reported.